
Peggy Turnage, mother of James Thompson, holds the affidavit that she says "falsely" accuses her son of attacking Marion County Sheriff's Office Chief Deputy Jeff Broom.
By Josh Mitchell/Informer Publisher
A local woman claims that the Marion County Sheriff’s Office has falsely accused her son of assaulting a deputy.
Marion County Sheriff’s Office Chief Deputy Jeff Broom, who is the law enforcement officer who was attacked, said his investigators would never falsely accuse anyone of a crime.
The suspect’s mother, Peggy Turnage of Marion County, said the Sheriff’s Office intimidated her son into confessing to a crime he did not commit. Her son, James Thompson, 35, was arrested on a charge of simple assault on a law enforcement officer March 10. If convicted, he faces up to five years in prison.
Broom said that because he is the victim in the case he has recused himself from the investigation, and Sheriff’s Office Chief Investigator Scott McKinney is heading up the matter. McKinney declined comment on the case and referred questions to Sheriff Berkley Hall who could not be reached after several attempts.
Broom said he was on duty Jan. 17 and driving down rural Williamsburg Road in Marion County when he saw a man walking at about 1 a.m. and stopped to see if he needed any help. Broom attempted to conduct a weapons search on the man when the suspect hit him in the head and escaped into the woods. After the attack, Broom called for help, and law enforcement searched the area for the suspect but could not locate anyone. Broom was unable to get a good description of the suspect and said he could not identify him.
About two months after the attack, Thompson was arrested and charged with simple assault on a law enforcement officer. Turnage said the Sheriff’s Office knows her son did not attack Broom but is charging him anyway. Broom knows who the real attacker is but is refusing to identify him as part of a “cover-up,” Turnage proclaimed.

This picture of James Thompson was taken off the Mississippi Department of Corrections Web site.
Broom balked at the cover-up accusation and said Thompson would not be charged if there was not evidence against him. “I assure you that they (Sheriff’s Office investigators) would have never put a charge on him without some facts,” said Broom. “They must have something or he wouldn’t be charged.”
Because he has recused himself from the investigation, Broom said he is unaware of what evidence the investigators might have against Thompson. The charges against Thompson are expected to be presented to a grand jury to decide whether he should be indicted for the assault on Broom.
This is not Thompson’s first run-in with law enforcement, having been convicted in 2007 on a charge of selling personal property subject to a lien in Marion County. He was sentenced to one year in prison and two years on post-release supervision.
He violated the terms of his post release by not paying his fines and not living where he was supposed to and was sentenced to two years’ house arrest last February. Now he is being held in the Jefferson County Correctional Facility in Fayette.
Despite her son’s criminal record, he would never try to hurt anyone, especially a law enforcement officer, said Turnage. Thompson lived on Williamsburg Road where the attack happened and heard sirens responding to the scene the night of the incident, said Turnage.
She said her son was interrogated by law enforcement officers at the Sheriff’s Office shortly after he was arrested in March at a Kokomo chicken house where he worked with his girlfriend. Five law enforcement officers pressured him to confess to a crime he did not commit, Turnage said, adding he was “scared” and “They wouldn’t let him have a lawyer.”
“Every time I think about it it gives me chills,” she said. “How can they do this? It’s just aggravating.”
Broom said it “hurts” and “saddens” him that Turnage would make such derogatory comments, but “she has a right to her opinion.”
“I’m here for the right thing,” said Broom, noting that criticism is a part of working in law enforcement.
Asked why she is so convinced her son is innocent of assaulting Chief Deputy Broom, Turnage said, “He wouldn’t hurt anyone. He has a tender heart. This is an innocent boy we’re talking about.”
Broom should be required to take a lie-detector test, said Turnage, adding, “They (Sheriff’s Office) want this case closed before anything else comes out.”
As for taking a polygraph test, Broom said he will do whatever is required if the case goes to court. “Her son will have his day in court,” Broom said.
Members of the Sheriff’s Office “lie for one another,” and Marion County is a “gangster town,” Turnage asserted. “Each one down there (at the Sheriff’s Office) protects each other’s back,” she said, noting that she has lost all respect for the Sheriff’s Office: “You should not send innocent people to jail.”
Sheriff Hall is “taking up for” Broom, and the sheriff should resign from office “if he can’t do is job.” The sheriff “needs to focus more on his investigators and officers. It’s very ‘snakey,’” Turnage stated.
Someone from outside Marion County needs to come here and “run the law enforcement,” Turnage said.